IGCSE argumentative essay | 2002 Oct-Nov | 'Honesty is the best policy.' Is this always true? Give



Question

You are advised to write between 350 and 500 words on the following topic:

‘Honesty is the best policy.’ Is this always true? Give your views.

Model Essay

“Honesty is the best policy” is a proverbial phrase that extols the virtues of truthfulness and integrity in all situations. While honesty is generally considered a fundamental moral principle, there are instances where it may not be practical or advisable to disclose the truth. The context, potential consequences, and impact on others must be carefully considered when determining whether honesty is the best course of action.

Honesty forms the foundation of trust and mutual respect in relationships, whether personal, professional, or societal. Being truthful fosters open communication, reduces misunderstandings, and strengthens interpersonal bonds. Moreover, honesty promotes accountability and ethical behavior, contributing to a harmonious and just society. In many cases, being honest is indeed the most ethical and honorable choice.

However, there are situations where complete honesty may not be practical or beneficial. For example, in certain interpersonal relationships, such as friendships or romantic partnerships, there may be times when disclosing the truth could cause unnecessary harm or strain the relationship. In such cases, exercising tact and discretion in communication may be more appropriate than blunt honesty.

The decision to be honest must take into account the context of the situation and the potential consequences of disclosing the truth. In some cases, the truth may be withheld or conveyed selectively to protect sensitive information or prevent harm to oneself or others. For example, in a professional setting, disclosing confidential information to unauthorized individuals could have legal or financial repercussions.

ADVERTISEMENT



There is a distinction between honesty and diplomacy, with the latter involving the tactful communication of truths in a manner that minimizes offense or conflict. Diplomacy often requires balancing honesty with sensitivity and consideration for the feelings of others. While honesty is important, it must be tempered with empathy and discretion to ensure effective communication and maintain positive relationships.

Cultural and social norms can also influence perceptions of honesty and the acceptability of withholding or distorting the truth in certain contexts. In some cultures, saving face or preserving harmony within a group may take precedence over absolute truthfulness. Understanding and respecting cultural differences can help individuals navigate diverse social situations with integrity and respect.

In conclusion, while honesty is generally considered a virtue and an essential component of ethical behavior, it is not always the best policy in every situation. The decision to be honest must be weighed against considerations such as context, consequences, and potential impact on others. Honesty should be balanced with empathy, discretion, and diplomacy to ensure effective communication and maintain positive relationships. Ultimately, the goal should be to cultivate a culture of integrity and trust while recognizing that absolute honesty may not always be practical or advisable.

Word Count: 440