IGCSE argumentative essay | 2007 May-Jun | 'Teachers should not try to be friends or role models.'



Question

You are advised to write between 350 and 500 words on the following topic:

‘Teachers should not try to be friends or role models.’ What are your views?

Model Essay

The role of a teacher in the educational and personal development of students is crucial. The statement “Teachers should not try to be friends or role models” suggests that educators should maintain a strictly professional and perhaps detached relationship with their students. However, I believe that teachers can and should strike a balance between maintaining professional boundaries and serving as friends and role models. This balanced approach can enhance the learning experience and positively influence students’ lives.

The concept of teachers as friends is often misunderstood. It does not mean that teachers should socialize with students or blur the lines of authority and respect. Instead, being a friend in the educational context implies being approachable, empathetic, and supportive. When teachers are friendly, students are more likely to feel comfortable and secure, which can create a positive and conducive learning environment.

For instance, a friendly teacher who listens to students’ concerns, provides encouragement, and shows understanding can foster a trusting relationship. This trust can lead to increased student engagement and participation in the classroom. Additionally, students are more likely to seek help and guidance from teachers they perceive as approachable, which can aid their academic and personal growth.

Teachers inherently serve as role models, whether they intend to or not. Their behavior, attitude, and values can significantly impact students. By embodying positive traits such as integrity, perseverance, kindness, and enthusiasm for learning, teachers can inspire students to adopt similar values and attitudes.

For example, a teacher who demonstrates a strong work ethic and passion for the subject matter can motivate students to develop a similar dedication to their studies. Similarly, a teacher who shows respect and empathy towards others can encourage students to cultivate these qualities in their own interactions. In this way, teachers as role models play a pivotal role in shaping students’ character and ethical development.

ADVERTISEMENT



While it is beneficial for teachers to be friendly and serve as role models, it is essential to maintain professional boundaries. Teachers must ensure that their approachability does not compromise their authority or the learning environment. Maintaining professionalism means upholding fair and consistent standards, respecting the teacher-student relationship, and avoiding favoritism.

By striking this balance, teachers can effectively manage their classrooms while still providing the support and inspiration that students need. This approach can lead to a more dynamic and engaging educational experience, where students feel valued and motivated to learn.

Some might argue that teachers who try to be friends or role models risk losing their objectivity and authority, potentially leading to disciplinary issues or favoritism. However, these risks can be mitigated by clearly defining the boundaries of the teacher-student relationship and ensuring that professional standards are always upheld.

In conclusion, the idea that teachers should not try to be friends or role models is a narrow perspective that overlooks the potential benefits of a balanced approach. Teachers who are approachable and serve as positive role models can significantly enhance the educational experience and personal development of their students. By maintaining professionalism while being supportive and inspirational, teachers can create a nurturing and effective learning environment that helps students succeed both academically and personally.

Word Count: 522